How to Fix a Running Toilet in About Half an Hour
A toilet that keeps running after you flush is easy to ignore. The hiss stops after a minute, or it comes back every twenty minutes in the middle of the night with a short refill, and you tell yourself you will look at it at the weekend.

A toilet that keeps running after you flush is easy to ignore. The hiss stops after a minute, or it comes back every twenty minutes in the middle of the night with a short refill, and you tell yourself you will look at it at the weekend. Meanwhile it can waste a surprising amount of water. A slow, silent leak past the flapper or flush valve seal often runs at somewhere between 20 and 200 litres a day, and a fill valve stuck open can lose far more than that.
The good news is that almost every running toilet comes down to one of three parts inside the cistern, and all three can be checked in about ten minutes with the lid off. You rarely need a plumber, and the replacement parts usually cost less than a takeaway meal.
Find out where the water is going first
Before buying anything, take the cistern lid off and set it somewhere flat, on a towel, because ceramic lids crack if they slide off a toilet seat. Look at the water level. There should be a line moulded into the back of the tank, or a mark on the overflow pipe, and the water should sit a couple of centimetres below the top of that overflow tube.
If the water is pouring into the overflow pipe, the fill valve is not shutting off. That is the problem in roughly a third of the toilets I have looked at in friends' houses, and it is the easiest to fix.
If the water level looks normal but you still hear refills every so often, water is escaping through the bottom of the tank into the bowl. Put six or eight drops of food colouring into the cistern, do not flush, and wait 15 minutes. If colour shows up in the bowl, the seal at the bottom is leaking. That points to the flapper on a lever flush, or the washer on a push button siphon or drop valve.
If neither happens and the noise is gone once you have the lid off, check the chain or linkage. A chain that is too short holds the flapper slightly open, and taking the lid off can be enough to move it.
Fixing a fill valve that will not shut off
The fill valve is the tall part on one side of the cistern, connected to the water supply underneath. Older toilets use a ball valve with a float on an arm. Newer ones use a float cup that slides up and down the valve body.
Start by lowering the float. On a ball valve, there is usually a screw where the arm joins the valve; turn it to drop the float slightly, or gently bend a brass arm downward. On a float cup, squeeze the clip on the adjustment rod, or turn the screw on top, and move the cup down by about a centimetre. Flush and watch. The valve should now shut off before the water reaches the overflow.
If adjusting does nothing, the washer inside the valve is probably worn or clogged with grit. Turn off the isolation valve on the supply pipe, usually a small screw you turn a quarter with a flat screwdriver. Flush to empty the tank. Many modern valves have a cap that twists off to expose a rubber diaphragm. Rinse it, check it for splits, and refit. A replacement diaphragm costs around three or four pounds. If your area has hard water, scale often jams the valve, and a soak in white vinegar, the same approach used for removing limescale from taps, can loosen it.
When the valve is cracked or the plastic has gone brittle, replace the whole unit. A universal bottom entry fill valve costs roughly 8 to 15 pounds and takes about half an hour to fit with an adjustable spanner.
Fixing a leak at the bottom of the cistern
A lever flush toilet, common in North America and in older UK bathrooms, has a rubber flapper hinged over a hole at the bottom. Over time the rubber warps or hardens, and water seeps around it.
Turn off the water, flush, and lift the flapper. Run a finger around the seat it closes onto. If you feel grit or a ridge of scale, wipe it clean with a scourer pad. Then look at the flapper itself. If it is stiff, misshapen, or leaves black marks on your fingers, it is finished. Unhook it from the two pegs on the overflow pipe and take it to the shop with you, because flappers come in 2 inch and 3 inch sizes and the wrong size will never seal.
Push button toilets, which are now standard in the UK and much of Europe, use a drop valve or flush valve with a large rubber washer instead. To reach it you usually twist the valve a quarter turn anticlockwise and lift it out of its base. The washer slides off the bottom. Take a photo of the make printed on the valve, since washers are not universal, though many hardware shops sell a mixed kit for about five pounds.
Check the chain while you are in there. It should have about 1 cm of slack when the flapper is shut. Too tight and it holds the flapper open; too loose and it can tangle under the seal.
Why jiggling the handle is a bad habit
The common advice is to jiggle the handle until the water stops. It works, which is why people keep doing it, but it treats the symptom and makes the underlying fault worse. Every jiggle bangs a worn flapper back into its seat at an angle, and a warped one can wedge itself so it seals for a few minutes before slipping again. You also stop noticing how often the toilet runs, which is the only clue you have to how much water is going.
The same goes for drop-in cleaning tablets. Many contain bleach or chlorine that softens rubber seals. If you have had to replace a flapper twice in two years, the tablet is the likely cause, and switching to cleaning the bowl by hand will make the next part last much longer.
When it is worth calling a plumber
Call someone if water is leaking onto the floor rather than into the bowl, because that suggests the seal between cistern and pan or the supply connection has failed. The same applies if the isolation valve will not turn, since forcing an old valve can snap it, and then you are shutting off the whole house. A crack in the ceramic is also not a DIY job. For everything inside the tank, though, the parts are cheap and there is not much that can go wrong if the water is off. If the toilet runs fine but drains slowly, that is a separate issue covered in the guide to unclogging a slow drain without chemicals, and you can find more small repairs in the home section.
FAQ
Why does my toilet keep running every few minutes?
Water is slowly leaking from the tank into the bowl, usually past a worn flapper or flush valve washer. The fill valve tops the tank back up, which is the refill you hear.
How much water does a running toilet waste?
A slow leak might lose 20 to 200 litres a day. A fill valve stuck open and spilling into the overflow can waste several times that.
Can I fix a running toilet without turning off the water?
You can adjust the float with the water on. For replacing a flapper, washer, or fill valve, turn off the isolation valve first.
How long does a toilet flapper last?
Typically four to five years, less in hard water areas or where chlorine tablets sit in the tank.
More in Home
Home
How to Fix a Squeaky Door Hinge Without Taking It Off
A door that shrieks every time someone heads to the bathroom at night will wake the whole house, and it tends to get worse as...
Home
How to Stop Condensation on Windows on Cold Mornings
You open the bedroom curtains on a cold morning and the glass is streaming, the sill is wet and there is a grey line of mould...
Home
How to Clean an Oven With Baking Soda Overnight
The oven door is brown, the floor is crusted with old drips, and every time you preheat it the kitchen smells faintly of last...