Lite Magazines logo Lite MagazinesA little bit of everything, explained clearly
Lifestyle

How to Sew On a Button So It Stays Put for Years

A button came off my coat on a cold platform last January, and I did what most people do: shoved it in a pocket, forgot about it for three weeks, then sewed it back on in ten minutes flat. It fell off again in February.

A shirt laid flat on a table with a needle, a reel of navy thread, a toothpick and a loose button beside the placket

A button came off my coat on a cold platform last January, and I did what most people do: shoved it in a pocket, forgot about it for three weeks, then sewed it back on in ten minutes flat. It fell off again in February. The second repair lasted two winters, and the only difference was about forty seconds of extra work at the end.

Sewing a button on is easy. Sewing one on so it stays is a slightly different job, and the part that makes the difference is the bit almost every quick guide leaves out. What follows is the method I use now, with the thread, the needle and the step that keeps the stitches from wearing through.

Why buttons fall off in the first place

Buttons rarely come loose because the knot failed. They come loose because the thread wore through where it rubs against the edge of the buttonhole, and that happens faster when the button sits flat against the fabric with no slack underneath it.

Factory buttons make this worse. Most are attached by machine with a chain stitch, which is quick and uses very little thread, and which unravels completely once a single loop breaks. That is why a button that has been fine for two years disappears in one afternoon. There was no warning stage.

The other common cause is washing. A front-loading machine drags a shirt cuff across the drum hundreds of times per cycle, and a shank button on a coat takes the same punishment from a seatbelt. Dry cleaning solvent also softens some plastic buttons enough that the holes start cutting the thread. If you have ever had three buttons go within a month of a dry clean, that is probably what happened.

What to have on the table

You do not need a sewing kit. You need five things, and four of them you likely own.

  • Polyester all purpose thread. A reel costs around two pounds and will outlast the garment. Polyester stretches slightly and resists abrasion better than cotton, which is the right trade for a button.
  • A sharps needle, size 7 or 8. The ones in hotel kits are usually too thick for shirting and will leave visible holes.
  • Small scissors or nail clippers. Biting the thread leaves a frayed end that will not pass through a needle on the next repair.
  • A toothpick, matchstick or cocktail stick. This is the part that matters. More on it below.
  • A thimble, only for coats. On wool and canvas you will be pushing hard enough to hurt a fingertip.

Match the thread to the garment rather than the button. A navy coat with a cream button looks better with navy thread, because the stitches read as part of the fabric. Shirt buttons are the exception, since white thread on white shirting disappears either way.

The method, start to finish

Allow eight minutes for a shirt button and twelve for a coat. Work in good light, and sit with the garment flat on a table rather than held in your lap.

  1. Find the old position. Do not guess from the other buttons. Fasten the garment, mark where the buttonhole falls with a pin or a dot of chalk, then unfasten. A button sewn two millimetres off centre pulls the placket crooked all day.
  2. Pick off the old thread. Any remaining loops on the back will stop the new button sitting flat. Nail clippers work better than scissors here.
  3. Cut about 50 cm of thread and use it single. Thread the needle, and leave a tail of around 10 cm.
  4. Anchor with two tiny stitches. Take two small stitches in the same spot on the front of the fabric, right where the button will sit. These hold everything and will be hidden. Skip the knot.
  5. Bring the needle up and slide the button on. Come up through one hole, then lay the toothpick across the top of the button, between the holes, before you go back down.
  6. Stitch over the toothpick six times. Four-hole buttons can be done as two parallel bars or as a cross. Parallel bars are stronger because the thread crosses the fabric in one direction. Count the passes, because five feels like enough and is not.
  7. Pull out the toothpick and lift the button. You now have a small bundle of loose thread between button and fabric. Wind the needle around that bundle five or six times, tight, from the button down to the cloth. This is the shank.
  8. Finish underneath. Push the needle through to the back, make three small stitches over each other into the same few fibres, then trim close. No knot, nothing to feel through the shirt.

That is it. The toothpick and the wrapping are the whole trick, and together they add under a minute.

Why I stopped tying knots

Nearly every guide tells you to knot the end of the thread before you start. I did it for years. Then a tailor in Leeds pointed out that the knot is the single weakest point in the repair, and that she had spent thirty years removing buttons whose knots had simply pulled through the weave.

Two small anchor stitches spread the load across more threads of fabric than a knot does, and they lie flat so there is no lump pressing against your chest under a fastened shirt. The same applies at the end. Three stitches worked into each other hold better than a knot and do not come undone when the loose tail inevitably gets caught.

The other habit worth dropping is doubling the thread for strength. Doubled thread tangles, and the two strands never take equal tension, so one carries nearly all the load and breaks first. Six single passes beat three doubled ones, and they look neater.

Different buttons, different handling

A shank button, the kind with a metal loop instead of holes, already has its own gap built in, so skip the toothpick. Stitch through the loop six times and still wrap the shank, because the loop will saw through unwrapped thread surprisingly fast.

Leather and metal buttons on a heavy coat need a backing button: a small flat button sewn on the inside, directly behind the main one, with the same stitches passing through both. It stops the thread tearing a hole in the wool. Coat makers do this as standard and it is the main reason a good coat keeps its buttons for a decade.

Shirt cuffs take more abrasion than any other button on a garment. If one cuff button keeps going, move the spare button from the inside hem of the shirt rather than buying a near match, and check the order you iron a shirt in while you are at it, since a hot iron dragged over a plastic button is another quiet way to lose one.

When to hand it over

I take three jobs to an alterations shop. Buttons on a tailored jacket sleeve, where the spacing is visible and getting it wrong is obvious. Anything with a covered or fabric-wrapped button, which usually needs replacing rather than resewing. And any repair where the buttonhole itself has frayed open, because that is a different skill and a sewing machine job.

Expect to pay somewhere between four and ten pounds for a handful of buttons at a local shop, often done while you wait. That is good value against a coat you stop wearing. The same logic applies to the other small repairs that keep clothes in rotation, like a zip that splits open behind the slider.

FAQ

How long should the shank be?

Roughly the thickness of the fabric the button has to pass through. A toothpick gives about two millimetres, which suits shirting and most jackets. For a thick wool coat, lay a matchstick or two toothpicks side by side instead.

Can I use dental floss for strength?

It holds, but it is slippery, bulky in the holes and almost impossible to anchor without a knot. I tried it on a rucksack strap and it worked there. On clothing it looks wrong and feels worse.

What if I have lost the button entirely?

Check the inside seam or hem for a spare first, then take the garment to a haberdashery and match in daylight. Buying one button to match is harder than buying a full set and changing all of them, which is what I usually end up doing.

Does the thread colour really matter?

On a shirt, no. On a coat with contrasting buttons, matching the fabric rather than the button makes an amateur repair almost invisible from a metre away.

Try it on a button that is still attached

Find the shirt button that feels loose and wobbly, cut it off before it leaves on its own, and sew it back with the toothpick and six passes. Doing it on a button you chose rather than one you lost takes the pressure off, and you will have the method in your hands next time it happens on a platform. More short repairs are collected in our lifestyle section.

CM
Clara Mensah

Clara writes clear step-by-step guides for everyday tasks, the kind of practical how-to that gets you from stuck to done.

More posts by Clara

More in Lifestyle

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto